Recently, ferc has been aggressively enforcing its power and anticipates antimanipulation enforcement will be a point of emphasis in the future. Ferc and cftc annual enforcement update energy legal blog. Total gas and therese tran tran, for violations of section 6c and 9a2 of the commodity exchange act and cftc regulations 180. Elements of robust compliance program fercs views as revealed through nerc reliability standards utilities and energy compliance and ethics conference houston, tx feb 22, 2016 bob lane compliance manager. Antimarket manipulation enforcement efforts ten years after.
Crossproduct manipulation in electricity markets harvard university. Antimarket manipulation antibribery and corruption. Ferc revised policy statement on penalty guidelines. Federal court upholds fercs expansive use of antimarket. On november 17, 2016, the enforcement staff of the federal energy regulatory commission ferc released two white papers providing an overview of the commissions anti market manipulation enforcement efforts and offered guidance on effective energy trading compliance practices. Fercs antimanipulation efforts need better balance andrew r. Openmarket manipulation under sec rule 10b5 and its. Some might argue that the recent spate of settlements at ferc leads to a lack of clarity about what constitutes market manipulation, and what does not. See ferc staff, white paper on antimarket manipulation. Court allows ferc market manipulation claim to proceed. Key elements of market manipulation identified by ferc staff.
Ferc regulates approximately 1,600 hydroelectric projects in. Detailing the first decade of ferc s enhanced enforcement authority granted by the energy policy act of 2005. Ferc enforcement staff has preliminarily concluded that the financial institution and the four traders each violated the commissions rules prohibiting market manipulation by engaging in a coordinated scheme of trading certain physically settled electricity products in an effort to benefit the financial institutions financiallysettled. Goldman sachs renewable power and the goldman sachs group as affiliates is essential for the commission to enforce the antimanipulation rule and just and reasonable rates. Conduct involving fraud and market manipulation poses a significant threat.
Market manipulation buckets of cheating device, scheme, or artifice to defraud not outright lying but open market conduct to create false market conditions. Ferc for its part states that its focus is on anticompetitive conduct that threatens market transparency. In market manipulation cases, ferc might seek information from third parties, such as other market participants who observed or may have been harmed by the conduct, isorto market operators, and other trading platforms and exchanges e. Ferc adopts final rule concerning prohibition of energy. On july 26, 2007, the commission issued an order to show cause and notice of proposed penalties. For a more detailed criticism of fercs antimanipulation rule and its problematic approach to electricitymarket manipulation, see doron f. District court for the southern district of ohio issued an order 1 substantially denying defendants motion to dismiss the federal energy regulatory commissions ferc or the commission complaint in ferc v. Fairness of the federal energy regulatory commissions enforcement. Ferc in its antimanipulation rule included natural persons as entities subject to the rule, and enforcement leadership has argued. Ferc noted that it would not impose sanctions for the same conduct in the event that the conduct violates both rule 2 and the new proposed antimanipulation rule. The rule extends fercs antimanipulation authority to energy entities that are not jurisdictional to the agency, such as governmentowned utilities and other market participants, said kelliher. Staff white paper on antimarket manipulation enforcement efforts.
Ferc asserted that the alj correctly determined that hunters trading strategy in february, march, and april 2006 constituted market manipulation because. Related positions with uneconomic trading and leverage. Federal energy regulatory commission ferc to police energy market manipulation. Ferc investigates market manipulation and imposes major. Office of enforcement white paper on anti market manipulation enforcement efforts ten years after epact 2005, nov. Corcoran issues in 2016 n umerous industry commentators have expressed skepticism and concern regarding the federal energy regulatory commissions fercs interpretation of what constitutes market manipulation. A new regulatory regime 3 the united states although the federal energy regulatory commission ferc established a separate formal enforcement function in 1978, very little happened until 2005 when congress enacted the energy policy act that established the present day antimanipulation authority. Ferc proposed to retain rule 2 for now, stating that it will address the possibility of revising or repealing rule 2 in the near future. Prohibition of energy market manipulation docket no. Such misconduct undermines the commissions goal of providing efficient energy services at a reasonable cost, because the financial harm imposed by such actions ultimately is borne by consumers.
Guidelines for albertas wholesale electricity market. This white paper is a product of the staff of the federal energy regulatory commission. Ferc revised policy statement on penalty guidelines society of corporate compliance and ethics conference february 2011 susan court. Perspectives on fercs enforcement programme as it relates to energy. Federal energy regulatory commission before commissioners.
Manipulation, anticompetitive conduct and violations of ferc rules, orders, tariffs 18. Conduct involving fraud and market manipulation poses a significant threat to the markets overseen by the commission, and is an enforcement priority. An adaptation of crossproduct manipulation models from. After receiving its market manipulation investigation authority from congress in epact 2005 and prior to the ferc office of enforcements investigation of napp, ferc actively investigated allegations of market manipulation. A 2012 article from the new york times reported that the federal energy regulatory commission ferc had taken aggressive steps against market manipulation in the electricity trading space against large investment banks. In addition, ferc enforcement staff released two white papers regarding the bounds of fercs prohibition on market manipulation and the features of an effective compliance program. The changes were embodied in the energy policy act of 2005. Ferc adopts broad antimarket manipulation rule modeled on. The second part will discuss the language of rule 10b5, its historical application to market manipulation generally, fercs antimanipulation rule and its relationship with rule 10b5, and the cftcs proposed rule. In a recent opinion denying the defendants motion to dismiss in ferc v.
Bay reiterated his position that powhatan violated fercs market manipulation rules, informing powhatans representative that there was a. Ferc adopts final rule concerning prohibition of energy market manipulation january 24, 2006 the federal energy regulatory commission ferc has adopted, effective upon publication in the federal register, final antimanipulation rules providing new authority to punish fraud in the electricity and natural gas markets order no. The dearth of cases shouldnot necessarily be attributedtoshortcomings of current antimanipulation laws, for uneconomic behavior simultaneously injects false information into the market andcontributes to an artificial price. One major change was to fercs ability to hand down penalties for market manipulation. Elements of robust compliance program fercs views as. Enforcement should create a procedures manual to instill further confidence in. Commission sec, and the federal energy regulatory commission ferc, and the antifraud enforcement efforts at the commodities futures trading commission cftc, though modified to reflect the unique features of wholesale petroleum markets. Epact 2005 greatly expanded the scope of the fercs authority by authorizing it to implement antimanipulation regulations. This overview comes verbatim from one of the commissions recent orders, and is frequently used by the commission to describe its authority. Enforcement prohibition of energy market manipulation ferc. Ferc adopts enforcement policy statement and proposes. Enforcement prohibition of energy market manipulation. Ferc gets green light to maintain antimanipulation push.
Ftc joins other agencies in policing oil industry market. Federal energy regulatory commissions fercs antimanipulation or gaming standards in the power and gas industry in a november 2016 report, ferc issued guidance on fraud and market manipulation that could. Commissioncftc, both of which have several antifraud rules, fercs antimanipulation rule is the only ferc rule governing fraud and manipulation cases. The guide to energy market manipulation charles river associates. The anti market manipulation white paper is available on the commissions website. Staff white paper on federal energy regulatory commission. Ferc should block potential energy market manipulation. Trader entered large manual orders in heating oil futures contracts without the intent to. Energy regulation is not a new topic, but after the enron scandal, congress made significant changes. Ferc alleged that coaltrains utc trades at issue constituted a deceptive scheme in violation of the fpas market manipulation provision, 16 u.
As written, fercs antimanipulation rule covers only instances. Electricity marketsrecent issues in market structure and. The final part of the paper will explore open market manipulation precedent in the securities and energy markets. Over the ensuing years, ferc has issued policies and procedures to implement that new authority, developed a robust office of enforcement, and standardized its enforcement process to ensure fairness and transparency for all investigative subjects. On october 20, 2005, the commission issued a notice of proposed rulemaking. Because the rule is broad and general in nature, its meaning in terms of how ferc interprets it can only be found in the details set forth in settlements and enforcementrelated orders. On april 21, 2011, the federal energy regulatory commission ferc issued an order affirming initial decision and ordering payment of civil penalty in connection with an administrative law judges alj initial decision that a natural gas trader for amaranth, brian hunter, engaged in market manipulation, in violation of section 4a of the natural gas act nga and part 1c. Staff white paper on antimarket manipulation enforcement efforts ten. Power market antimanipulation training contact our sales team. The federal energy regulatory commissions office of enforcement oe has been on the march, its antimanipulation and civil penalty authority under the energy policy act of 2005 epact 2005 1 in hand, targeting market participants for a range of activities in the wholesale electricity and natural gas markets. Ferc antimanipulation enforcement and the barclays.
Any views expressed herein are those of staff and do not necessarily reflect the views of. The fercs antimanipulation rule is codified in 18 c. Fercs staff white paper on antimarket manipulation enforcement. The market manipulation rule has engendered substantial comment in. Anti market manipulation enforcement efforts ten years after epact, summarizes recent commission and federal court case law regarding development of the commissions anti manipulation doctrine and identifies factors staff considers when deciding whether to pursue or close allegations of manipulation. Gsemna following an investigation into whether gsemna violated fercs antimanipulation regulations from may 2011 to september 20. Detailing the first decade of fercs enhanced enforcement authority granted by the energy policy act. A framework for the analysis of market manipulation. On february 1, 2017 ferc issued an order approving a settlement between its office of enforcement enforcement and houstonbased power marketer gdf suez energy marketing na, inc. Consistent with securities law precedent, scienter i. On november 17, 2016, the enforcement staff of the federal energy regulatory commission ferc released two white papers providing an overview of the commissions antimarket manipulation enforcement efforts and offered guidance on effective energy trading compliance practices. The ferc responded in january 2006 by issuing order no.
1240 425 465 890 341 634 1240 1362 6 266 1185 506 870 899 671 286 189 587 956 1004 954 173 97 222 548 622 592 349 934 1463 927 316 907 1190 898 1046 751 210 1058 707 473 35 627 594 940 517 1295 1048